Parts-Bin Pinecone

A look at my fixed-wheel Brother Cycles Pinecone.

I have the good fortune, or possibly misfortune, I have not decided yet, to have the sort of friends who, when presented with the question “do you think I should build a fixed wheel mountain bike?” would invariably say “yes!”. Inevitably then that is what happened. It isn’t particularly surprising really, I’d been kicking the idea around in the recesses of my mind for quite a few years, but rationality always trumped frivolity if you like, and the closest I ever got was to stick some fatter rubber on my AllDay and tell myself that I didn’t need another bike. Yeah, silly I know, one always needs another bike.

Brother Cycles Pinecone

It also has something to do with getting older I think.. once I was old enough for cycling to become a serious business, as it does for many young folk of a competitive bent, and in my case when I started road racing at university, the “just for the heck of it” aspect of childhood took a back seat in favour of an inevitable focus on going fast and far and winning stuff, or trying to anyway. There comes a time in life however when the imperative for “smiles not miles” begins to assert itself more strongly.. after all, if you’ve been riding all your life, there comes a point at which you’re probably only going to get slower anyway so you may as well embrace it. Besides, cycling is, to borrow a well used metaphor, a broad and colourful church with many flavours to embrace and enjoy. Certainly a fixed wheel mountain bike when measured in terms of its ability to cover terrain efficiently is not going to score very highly at all, and as such is likely to remain a perpetual head-scratcher to most folk. In my case however, having been something of a fixed wheel addict for decades, and living where I do with its network of relatively unchallenging trails, and when measured in terms of how wide my grin is when riding it, then it makes perfect sense.

with the fixed wheel forever turning I feel like I’m flowing across the landscape, like water, in a way that I’ve never achieved when riding with a freewheel.

From time to time over the past few years, when bored with work, I had found myself trawling eBay for old MTB frames with such a project half-in-mind but never really found anything that floated my boat so to speak. It’s much easier to convert a bike to singlespeed than it is to fixed wheel – a chain tensioner can’t be used with a fixed wheel so it’s necessary to find a frame with horizontal dropouts, an eccentric bottom-bracket, or use a hub with an eccentric axle such as the White Industries ENO. To find a frame with horizontal dropouts it’s necessary to go back a really long way.. mid eighties or earlier, and those are rare, and often expensive. Eccentric BBs are scarce too for the reason that it’s the sort of thing that only a niche framebuilder would usually consider, and for the last option I would need to find a frame that inspired me sufficiently to want to spend the money on such a hub, and while I kind of like vintage MTBs there’s an awful lot of rubbish to trawl through and nothing ever inspired me unless it was too rare and expensive to want to muck about with. As an aside Velo Orange do make an eccentric BB that can be fitted to a normal shell, however it isn’t particularly pretty, and uses external bearings, with all their drawbacks (fixed chainline, modern cranks, shorter bearing life), so that wasn’t going to happen either.  Enter the Brother Cycles Pinecone with its “track ends”, and really cool paint.

Really very cool paint.. that sparkle! There is also a super yellow-splatter version that really taps into a 90’s vibe. The seatclamp is that colour because that’s what was in the bits box, and the Condor Strada seatpost (new) is a really good value inline post for a fraction of the cost of, say, a Thomson.

It probably wouldn’t hurt to point out that I don’t have any kind of financial arrangement with Brother Cycles despite owning three of their frames (my Mk1 Big Bro, and my AllDay being the others), I just really like what they’re doing, particularly with the Pinecone and Mr Wooden – making the kind of bikes they want to ride and fiddle with rather than the kind of bikes that the market might dictate that they should be making. Sticking with older standards, such as rim brakes and quick release dropouts, makes available a vast range of interesting, and low cost, secondhand parts from eBay, enthusiast forums and the like, with which it’s easy to put together something truly original when starting with a canvas such as the Pinecone frame. This one is a genuine parts-bin bike, just not entirely my own parts bin.. I’m lucky to have a friend who also has an interesting parts bin, and I did have to go to the forums to find a front brake I was happy with. The only new-bought parts are rims, spokes, seatpost, brake lever, and chainring, and small bits like grips and crank bolts. It’s also helpful that a fixed wheel doesn’t need very many parts at all. There’s a build list at the end of this post because, well, bikes. I should probably also point out that this isn’t intended to be a review in the conventional sense, rather it’s just me rambling on about something I love and saying “this is a really cool and fun thing, in my opinion…” :-)

Love the new metal head badges. I’m not generally big on boutique headsets, the Cane Creek Forty has always proven itself to be durable, reliable, good value, and should a new bearing be needed, they are cheap and easy to get hold of.

As for riding it, well, I expected the first time out to be reminded of how it was to be a teenager riding around on early Muddy Foxes and Marins in the second half of the Eighties, after all the Pinecone very much has some of that original ATB (All-Terrain Bike) DNA, and that did happen to a certain extent, however, and this may be due to the extreme simplicity of my bike, I was transported somewhere in my memories that I had not been for years, possibly decades. When I was around 10 or 11 years old, my brother and I both had basic singlespeed Raleighs – 24″ wheels I think, skinny steel tubes as was normal then, and a chromed steel riser bar. We thought of them as our “scramblers”.. and with friends we went “scrambling” .. bashing through the woods, across the fields, down on the beach (much to father’s disgust), and bashing around the boatyard where we lived with its cobbled together jumps and berms. In a world that seems increasingly ‘challenging’, and with the perhaps inevitable nostalgia for childhood that afflicts those burdened with work and other responsibilities, it felt quite a profound moment. Yeah, silly and dramatic I know but that’s how it felt.

if the only people you’re racing are your mates then the gear you’ve got doesn’t really matter too much so long as it puts a smile on your face…

With regard to the riding experience in general, I find there is a lightness to the way it rides, a springiness that complements the simplicity of it beautifully, no doubt something to do with the skinny, heat-treated tubing. On singletrack it is an absolute delight, with the fixed wheel forever turning I feel like I’m flowing across the landscape, like water, in a way that I’ve never achieved when riding with a freewheel. Steep, rooty climbs with a relatively high fixed gear are, umm, challenging.. but that’s kind of the point, I’ve got some skills to work on. Built as shown here it works out at about a 62″ gear which feels spot on for local terrain. I imagine it would be a bit of a chocolate teapot in the Alps, and probably the Lake District too… If fixed wheel wasn’t your thing, it would make a fantastic singlespeed, or you could just, you know, put gears on it, I suppose..! It would still be great. Handily the frame does come with a removable derailleur hanger.

The Tumbleweed Persuader bar had been on my bench for a while, intended for my old ECR ahead of future adventures, but ended up here in a role for which it feels a perfect match. I borrowed the stem off another bike while I decide, over a few weeks of riding, how much reach feels right. I have a feeling it’ll stay put and something else will go back on that other bike.
The redundant rear threaded v-brake bosses are plugged with a couple of spare chainring bolts padded out with Teflon plumbers tape. Proper threaded plugs can be bought, but this is better I reckon…. I used Vittoria Mezcal tyres simply because I had a pair handy. They work well around here.
Crank is an early 90s RaceFace Turbine with a Surly 94bcd 36T stainless steel chainring. Running on a UN55 bottom bracket with a 113mm axle gives a perfect 51.5mm chainline to match the fixed cog on the rear hub. The drivetrain barely whispers. I love the old square taper Turbine crank.. it feels like a modern classic, and looks so good. Blue Lug crank bolts.
The rear hub is a Surly Ultra New 135mm OLN hub scrounged from a mate’s parts bin. It had been built into a wheel once but never used. Ideal.
Bit posh but it needed using up.. the cog is an EAI Gold Medal, 16T, with a titanium-nitride coating, left over from my time trialling days. With the 27.5 x 2.25″ rubber and a 36T chainring it gives me a gear of around 62″. Perfect.
I saw this, new at the time, XT M752 hub for sale years ago for just a tenner so grabbed it thinking “that’ll come in handy one day”.. and look! It did! It was missing a quick release so has a no-nonsense Blue Lug one fitted. Bombproof hubs, I had them on my old Thorn Nomad for years and they carried me to all sorts of wild and wonderful places around the world. I used Ryde Zac 421 rims –  at just £25ish they’re not posh but are a very nice, high quality double-eyeletted box section rim. I had initially wanted to use polished rims but choice is limited in the world of 27.5″ rim brake rims… the only real option would have been a Velocity Ciffhanger, but at £100 or so each it just made no sense. For anyone who cares, I used Sapim Race double-butted spokes.
The frame has disc tabs too so can run either discs or v-brakes/cantis. I used a vintage XTR v-brake because it felt right for the bike, and being a fixed gear, most of my braking is through my legs anyway. The performance advantage of discs would be largely wasted. I picked the brake up off a forum for not too many £, and while it was pretty rough and sticky, being XTR it’s insanely over-engineered – fully rebuildable with a double ball race in each brake. A happy evening pulling them to bits for a service restored them to “like new”.
Brake pulling duties are handled by a single Dia-Compe MX-2 lever. The quality far exceeds the price of just £24. Pull ratio is switchable between v-brake/cable-disc and cantilever brake, which might be handy one day.
Enjoying some fine October sunshine. I love the simplicity of bikes like this…. if the only people you’re racing are your mates then the gear you’ve got doesn’t really matter too much so long as it puts a smile on your face.
Non-suspension corrected geometry means a large frame triangle for a bag.. it would make a super bikepacking rig with its ability to clear a 2.6″ tyre. Just maybe not as a fixed wheel… much, anyway. I’ll order some bright yellow x-pac fabric over the winter and sew myself a bag or too to fill some space.
Now that the crowds have buggered off, this is a lovely spot to ride down to with a flask of coffee on a weekend morning…
.. and enjoy a spot of wave-watching and mind-surfing.
This was Sunday. Looking at the forecast it felt likely to be the last fine weather for a long time. It is the same pattern every year – in the third week of October a big storm sweeps in, and then the weather is horrible until March. The forecast for later this week is severe gales and heavy rain.. followed by.. wind and rain. No more merely damp trails :-( Still, a fixed wheel with loads of clearance is perfect for the mud…
Two weeks prior to this I’d been lounging in the sea in nothing but a pair of shorts. This morning, in the valley bottoms under the trees my tyres were crunching through the first patches of ice for the season.
Weirdly however, the trees are mostly still green.. albeit starting to brown. The drought meant a very many leaves were shed prematurely.
Anyway, that’ll do for now, one final pic to remind me of what a dry trail looks like over the next few months, and just because. You might be able to tell, but in case not, I’m really into this bike :-)

 

Here’s the build list, I think I’ve remembered everything:

  • Frame & Fork Brother Cycles Pinecone, L
  • Cranks RaceFace Turbine square taper (I-beam version)
  • Chainring Surly stainless steel 36T 94bcd
  • BB Shimano UN55, 113mm
  • Cog EAI Gold Medal, 16T
  • Chain KMC Z1 1/8″
  • Hubs Surly Ultra New rear, Shimano XT M752 front
  • Rims Ryde Zac 421 27.5″
  • Tyres Vittoria Mezcal 27.5×2.25
  • Front Brake Shimano XTR M951
  • Brake Lever Dia-Compe MX-2
  • Saddle Brooks Cambium C17 All-Weather
  • Seatpost Condor Strada
  • Handlebars Tumbleweed Persuader
  • Stem Thomson X4
  • Headset Cane Creek Forty
  • Pedals Shimano M520
  • Weight Somewhere between 24 and 25lbs
Filed under: Bikes & Gear, Fixed Gear

15 thoughts on “Parts-Bin Pinecone”

  • Gday Mike, Dave here……
    Brilliant! Now youv’e put ideas in my head. I ride a Surly lowside when I’m in the mood for some real fun, or a ride down BMX memory lane. It’s not a fixie, but with its single speed it has some of the same fun potential, and I can always pretend and keep spinning – downhill, or on the flat anyway! Some of the hills I hit on the trails here push me into jumping off, and running at a plod-like crawl (I am 66 now after-all!), while pretending, between gasps for air, to be a cyclo-x rainbow contender. And then with the next gasp and cough, the reality hits in……….

    Great write up and beautiful pics as always Mike. Cheers.

    BTW, on the topic of pics, I have a Fuji X series photographic project that I’m working on with two others – an EBook on ‘The Natural Wonders of the World’. It ties in with my writing on ‘Creating a regenerative future and planetary health’. I’ve left my website address in your form if you’re interested, and I’ll tell you more. Don’t want to take up your space here. Signing out for now from Downunda. Cheers Mike.
    Dave :-)

    • haha, sorry! That’s awesome though, I really liked the look of the Lowside when it first appeared, it very much has that giant BMX sort of a vibe to it. It’s great to hear from someone who has actually got one (it was really expensive over here, seemingly way more than the usual $ to £ inflation that happens) and I wondered how many people actually bought one.
      Cheers for the link, I’ve just subscribed and will have a read!

  • Oh goodness your scrambling reminded me of the scrumping we did on our Raleighs in the orchard of an abandoned mental asylum.
    The ride home involved a very steep hill so I let air out of a tyre once I got to a call box, “I’ve got a flat, can you come get me?” It worked twice 😂 Good memories!

    • oh that’s brilliant, what a great little story! Reminded me of how useful our bicycles were for a spot of scrumping as kids. I think we must be of a generation that was just left to roam! Love the flat tyre wheeze!

  • 😍sehr schön geworden 👍, In Leyland habe ich einen tollen Fahrrad Shop gefunden, aber keine gebrauchten Brompten . Blackpool, Preston und Manchester sind cool, ich komme wieder, LG Thomas

  • Thank you Mike for the pics, story and thoughts
    I have a surly 1*1, not so far from a pinecone I think, but the brother’s cycle seems better with heat treated crmo, better paint job et better tyre clearance

    • Nice! the 1×1 is a classic Surly from the days when it felt like they were genuinely innovating… I have to say though, given the price of Surly frames these days, the Brother Cycles offerings look incredibly good.. and the paint really is very good indeed!

  • Hi Mike, it seems we’re always on the same path of tinkering about bikes and putting some ‘new’ steeds on the trail. Beautiful bike you built again and I really admire the 27.5″ mtb-tires, such a versatile set of wheels for all kind of trails. I put the 2.4″ variant of those Mezcals this September under my steel All-City Gorilla Monsoon and had lot’s of fun descending rocky alpine tracks overtaking the influencer bikepacking crowds on their carbon and skinny tired ‘gravel’ bikes.

    Last year the Dutch fixed-gear community started a tracklocross competition. Looking for photo opportunities I converted my singlespeed On-One Pompino to brakeless-fixed. Well, it already was fixed for doing low-maintenance duties around town with a basket, but I removed the brakes and basket and put a 830mm wide handlebar on it as that is apparently the tracklocross esthetics ;-) I relate to that feeling of flowing over the tracks, and getting pushed forward by little potholes. Pointing the thing downwards with an immediate corner is still scary being brakeless and all. But I just take my time. Last Saturday’s alleycat around Amsterdam city-center around rush-hour was a whole new experience though. Kind of not so much thinking about braking but more about slowing doing and seeing different routes I guess. A lot like riding skinny-tired cross bikes on muddy or sandy tracks.

    Racing among friends is one of the greatest things I learned from the singlespeed community and I’m happy to have made new friends by this tracklocross thing. Now I’m even riding around on our local trails on the fixed-gear bike in mud and beautiful sunsets and that’s really liberating. Pompino geometry doesn’t do good things to my lower back, so I’m contemplating to having something build by our local builder that I can swap between tracklocross and SSCX.

    Enjoy the winter and the elements. Next year’s tracklocross championships are in Scotland.

    • hey, Michele, I always look forward to hearing your thoughts and experiences from the single cog world. The tracklocross stuff sounds like brilliant fun. I did ride a brakeless bike in the lanes around here for a while years ago but figured that sooner or later I’d end up as little more than a damp spot on the road… the thought of doing it now with the way people drive and the massive cars they’re in is just horrifying… a safe environment on the other hand would be hilarious.. when I’m out on the Pinecone I tend to avoid using the brake as much as possible, partly out of principle, but also partly because no matter how much toe-in is on the pads, that flavour of v-brake squeal terribly…
      I do envy your access to a singlespeed community, there really isn’t one all the way down here in Cornwall so I’m mostly on my own, unless I travel for hours to catch up with friends elsewhere. There isn’t really much of an ‘alt-bike’ scene here at all, although.. there is the local “shit bike club”, the goal of which is to ride out on the worst possible bikes it’s possible to find on Facebook Marketplace or at the dump… they do seem to have fun but I’m just not wired that way, I have no desire to make room for, or ride, (or exchange any ££ at all for) an absolute piece of crap. It’s great they’re doing it though, and the search for the worst piece of crap bike is apparently highly competitive, and having seen a few of their bikes, they really can be very shit indeed :-)
      Anyway thanks for your kind words re the Pinecone. I think bikes are like grown-up Meccano, or Lego, for me… and it’s these sort of bikes that reward tinkering and fiddling without necessarily costing an arm and a leg. The 27.5″ wheel does seem to hit a nice sweetspot,.. light and manoeuvrable, and rolls well. It’s kind of a shame the industry seems to be currently going all in on 32″.. and maybe 30.5″..
      Enjoy the trails..
      Cheero!

      • Hi Mike
        What do you think about tubeless ? Into the shit bike category or not ?
        Your bike make me think about thé marin larkspur, in some points (big tyre, blue colours, anciens quick release axel, crmo frameset – obviously better with yours of course – …)

        I really like to read the posts and comments. It is like fresh air. Thank you

        • Re tubeless, hhahaha :-) well it has its place… I guess..
          Some of those old Marins were lovely. I had a Pine Mountain all the way back in 1988…. Showing my age a bit… Thank you for the kind words and I’m happy you’re enjoying the blog, thanks for checking in, it’s much appreciated. Cheers!

          • ooops, sorry! I should have known, I saw that bike online recently and noted how similar it was the Pinecone.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.